Mohamed Essalah Berredjem Contact
Model quality check

Health economic model quality check, before the assessor does it.

An independent, cell-by-cell verification of your cost-effectiveness or budget impact model, read the way an HTA assessor reads it. You receive an anomaly log, a report and a walkthrough.

The service

A second look, cell by cell.

A cost-effectiveness or budget impact model can contain errors that nobody notices until an HTA assessor asks a question. Each question costs time, and some delay access.

I verify the model independently, from inputs to outputs, before submission. I read it the way an assessor will.

I work with HEOR consultancies that want an independent check on a model they built, and with manufacturers preparing a submission.

An NDA can be signed before any file is shared.

What is checked

From inputs to uncertainty analyses.

  • Inputs. Every parameter against its source.
  • Formulas and links. Calculations verified cell by cell, with hard-coded values and broken links flagged.
  • Structure and logic. Model structure, transitions, time horizon and discounting.
  • Sensitivity analyses. Deterministic and probabilistic analyses, scenarios and their consistency.
  • Outputs. Results checked against the report or dossier they feed.
  • Validation. How far the model has been validated, documented with AdViSHE.
Frameworks

Published standards, step by step.

The check follows published references. The Philips checklist (2006) and the ISPOR-SMDM good practices complement them where relevant. The full list is in the frameworks section of the home page.

TECH-VER (2019)

Checklist to verify the technical implementation of a model, from inputs to uncertainty analyses.

AdViSHE (2016)

Tool to document and assess how well a health economic model has been validated.

CHEERS 2022

Checklist to report health economic evaluations clearly and completely.

What you receive

Findings you can act on.

01

Scoping call

Model, data, deadline. Clear scope and quote.

02

Verification

The model is checked against TECH-VER and AdViSHE.

03

Anomaly log and report

Every finding is logged. A CHEERS 2022 report is prepared.

04

Walkthrough

A call to go through the findings and the corrections.

Working together

Clear pricing.

Option 1

Hourly

90 euros per hour, for ad hoc checks and ongoing projects.

Option 2

Fixed fee

A fixed fee per deliverable, quoted after the scoping call.

FAQ

Questions and answers

What is a health economic model quality check?

An independent verification that a model is correctly implemented and documented: inputs, formulas, structure, sensitivity analyses and outputs. It is also called model verification or technical validation, and it is done before the model goes to an HTA body.

When should a model be checked?

Ideally before the dossier is submitted, once the model is stable and the report is drafted. A check on the final version avoids technical questions from the assessor.

Which standards do you follow?

TECH-VER for technical verification, AdViSHE for the documentation of validation, and CHEERS 2022 for reporting. The Philips checklist and the ISPOR-SMDM good practices complement them.

What types of models can you check?

Cost-effectiveness and budget impact models prepared for HTA submissions. The platform and the size of the model are discussed during the scoping call.

Can you work as a subcontractor for our consultancy?

Yes. I work alongside your modellers and project leads, on the parts that you assign, and an NDA can be signed upfront.

How much does a model check cost?

90 euros per hour, or a fixed fee per deliverable quoted after a scoping call.

Contact

Let's talk about your project.

A 30-minute call, at a time that suits you. Prefer 15 minutes or 1 hour?

Your details are used only to answer your request. See the privacy policy.

Book a call